Yes, Sukhadia makes a delicious Masala Dosa and this was probably the MOST delicious Masala Dosa I've had at Sukhadia's, but if you have a nut allergy like I do, their sometimes secret ingredient of cashews is not good news...
I've been to Sukhadia's many times for their excellent $5.99 all vegetarian Indian buffet and also for their dosas. The masala dosa is my favorite and Sukhadia makes a very good one. The dosa is chewy and flavorful and oh, yeah, HUGE--I had to lean back to get it all in the shot. It comes with a little cup of dal and a cup of coconut chutney. The potato filling this time was exceptionally good. Nicely spiced and studded with tasty onions. Oh and something crunchy. Something crunchy that has the texture of a nut. Nuts in my masala dosa? I've never had a masala dosa there with nuts and Blondie and I specifically asked the waiter two or three times if it had nuts! Very frustrating. Fortunately I don't have as severe reaction to nuts as some of my friends who are also allergic, but I try to limit my exposure as much as I can and I'm always good about asking if dishes have nuts. Turns out the communication breakdown was in the kitchen where the chef (I'm presuming a new guy) sometimes at his whim puts a little bit of cashews in the dosa. ARGH!
Lesson learned...next time I'm at Sukhadia's I will peer behind the counter, make eye contact with the chef and make him understand that I can't have nuts in my food. If you don't have a problem with nuts then I'd recommend this dosa without reservation. I have no idea what the final bill was because Blondie paid it as I ran out to Duane Reade in search of Benadryl.
Sukhadia's Gokul 17 West 45th Street New York City, NY (between 5th and 6th Avenue) Phone : 212 395-7300 Fax : 212-395-2552